History confirms that Eddie Mahoney was South's greatest footballer before World War 2, begging comparisons between he and the other great Eddie post World War 2 - Eddie Schwerdt. Both hold a tally of three Mail Medals each, but arguably Mahoney peaked in the leaner times of the 1930s and 40s when South had been all but decimated by the Rovers conspiracy.

Younger brother of stalwart Gerald, a young Eddie Mahoney revealed himself to be a football prodigy in the 1927 seconds, ultimately becoming an A Grade champion from 1929 until 1946. Mahoney would play more than 100 games for South, for which he would be awarded with life membership.

In his debut senior year, as "just a skinny kid" Eddie helped propel the South A Grade to the landmark 1929 flag under Chum Rau. He soon established himself as an accomplished on-baller, greatly contributing in the losing Grand Final of 1930, the premiership of 1931, and another losing Grand Final in 1932, before the dark years set in.

Mahoney set a GFA record in 1933, in the June 10 seventeen goal victory over Roseworthy College, by kicking 19 goals as a rover changing in the back pocket. He continued to raise his standards in the following seasons, consistently representing the GFA, and finishing runner-up in the 1934 Mail Medal count.

In 1935, Charlie Nottle provided a trophy for the best performer in the South A Grade who did not receive an Association trophy. That is, a best and fairest award for the Club's highest vote poller in the Mail Medal. Back pocket Eddie Mahoney won the trophy.

By 1936, South was entering our worst years in performance ever beneath the impending shadow of World War Two. But despite the lack of team success, a "double-act" emerged to become our only shining light. Just like Lockett and Winmar, South fans flocked to see the great Eddie Mahoney - and his new offsider, a young star named Howard Abbott.

Abbott, the club's leading goalkicker, was second in the GFA with his 67 goals in 1936, while Eddie Mahoney won the first of his three Mail Medals. Resisting the temptation of league footy, Mahoney then went on to win the 1937 and 1938 association best and fairest awards, and captained the club until 1940, but Abbott was eventually lured to Port Adelaide where he became an outstanding full forward.

Eddie announced his retirement from active football at the start of 1946, so a benefit night was organised for him. About 60 members generously supported his Testimonial at the High Street Hall. Mahoney had played for 19 years, winning the Mail Medal three years in a row and numerous club trophies including the Coates Shield for 1937, 1938 and 1939. Eddie continued his support until 1948 as the A Grade assistant coach.

Of course, Eddie's wife Myra, also later proved to be a magnificient club person and life member in her own right.